← All cases

Self-Driving Cars Part 2

The self-driving cars case explores the ethical problems created when people become too optimistic about a new technology. In 2016, Joshua Brown died after his Tesla Model S, operating with Autopilot engaged, failed to identify a tractor-trailer crossing the highway. Brown had previously posted videos showing his confidence in Tesla’s Autopilot system, but the NTSB later concluded that he had over-relied on the automation and did not fully understand its limits. At the same time, the NTSB also criticized Tesla because the system could be used in conditions for which it was not designed. The main ethical question is whether companies are responsible for preventing foreseeable misuse of technologies that users may trust too much. This case highlights the need for a critical attitude toward technology: self-driving cars may eventually save lives, but engineers must still design them carefully, communicate their limits honestly, and prevent users from treating partially autonomous systems as more capable than they really are.

Videos

The ethical dilemma of self-driving cars - Patrick Lin